LATEST
外 Waitan Ludi Policy Terminal China industrial-policy monitor · updated 2026-10-25
← Directive tracer · the directive's page

国务院关于进一步规范和监督罚款设定与实施的指导意见

Guiding Opinions of the State Council on Further Standardising and Supervising the Setting and Enforcement of Fines

国发〔2024〕5号 · 国务院 · dated 2024-02-09, 1005 days ago

5 / 31
provinces with a held document citing it
0 / 6
of the provinces whose provincial-government documents are listed in full
7
local documents citing it: 3 prefecture, 4 province
past window
Past the usual window (2024-05-03 to 2024-10-25): three in four restatements we measured came within 259 days.

Found by citation: a local document that names this directive by its number or 《title》. One that restates it without naming it is not counted here. A citation shows the document names the directive, not that it carries all of it out, and a gap is not a finding of non-compliance.

Timeline

day 0day 1005
● large: provincial document · small: city or countyshaded: middle half of measured lags (84–259 days), dashed: mediansolid line: today

By province

The first held document from each province that cites the directive: from the provincial government, its departments, or a city or county. In the 6 provinces marked "full" we hold the provincial government's own document list (省政府 and its General Office), so a gap there is more telling; but a response can come from a department, be published outside that list, or name the directive without its number or title. Elsewhere "none found" may only mean we have not collected the document.

Zhejiang
2024-07-08 · 150 days · prefecture
Inner Mongolia
2024-07-12 · 154 days · province
Hubei
2024-10-28 · 262 days · prefecture · 3 docs
Tibet
2024-11-19 · 284 days · province
Yunnan
2025-08-20 · 558 days · province
Anhui · full
none found; provincial list held
Beijing · full
none found; provincial list held
Fujian · full
none found; provincial list held
Guangdong · full
none found; provincial list held
Hainan · full
none found; provincial list held
Hunan · full
none found; provincial list held
Chongqing
none found (partial coverage)
Gansu
none found (partial coverage)
Guangxi
none found (partial coverage)
Guizhou
none found (partial coverage)
Hebei
none found (partial coverage)
Heilongjiang
none found (partial coverage)
Henan
none found (partial coverage)
Jiangsu
none found (partial coverage)
Jiangxi
none found (partial coverage)
Jilin
none found (partial coverage)
Liaoning
none found (partial coverage)
Ningxia
none found (partial coverage)
Qinghai
none found (partial coverage)
Shaanxi
none found (partial coverage)
Shandong
none found (partial coverage)
Shanghai
none found (partial coverage)
Shanxi
none found (partial coverage)
Sichuan
none found (partial coverage)
Tianjin
none found (partial coverage)
Xinjiang
none found (partial coverage)

Every citing document

2024-07-08 +150d Zhejiang · 杭州市 杭州西湖风景名胜区管委会2024年法治政府建设工作要点
prefecture · compare text
2024-07-12 +154d Inner Mongolia 内蒙古自治区公安机关包容审慎监管执法清单
province · compare text
2024-10-28 +262d Hubei · 襄阳市 襄阳市农业农村局关于推行包容审慎监管执法进一步优化法治化营商环境的实施方案
prefecture · compare text
2024-11-19 +284d Tibet 自治区司法厅关于印发《西藏自治区司法行政行政处罚裁量权基准适用规定(试行)》和律师、公证、司法鉴定三个领域行政处罚裁量权 基准(2024年版)的通知
province · compare text
2025-08-20 +558d Yunnan 司法部会同国家发展改革委、全国工商联印发关于进一步发挥行政复议监督职能规范涉企行政执法的指导意见
province · compare text
2025-10-11 +610d Hubei 省药品监督管理局关于印发《湖北省药品监管领域依法不予处罚事项清单》的通知 Notice from the Provincial Drug Administration on the Issuance of the ‘List of Matters Exempt from …
province · compare text
2025-12-29 +689d Hubei · 襄阳市 市住房和城市更新局关于印发《行政执法包容审慎“四张清单”》的通知
prefecture · compare text